Tags
Motown M 1050 (A), October 1963
b/w Devil In His Heart
(Written by Carolyn Crawford)
Carolyn, not “Caroline”. Bloody Wikipedia. (Although she did cut an LP with Hamilton Bohannon in the late Seventies called My Name Is Caroline, which might have muddied the waters a bit, so maybe we’ll let them off this time.)
Anyway, loud-voiced teenager Carolyn Crawford came to Hitsville via victory in a Tip Top Bread / WCHB radio talent contest when she was 13. The contest saw her sending in a predetermined number of bread wrappers to gain entry at a local amateur talent show, the winner of which would get some prizes including a Motown audition.
But that makes her sound like a modern-day reality show contestant. In fact, despite her tender years Carolyn was an accomplished songwriter and pianist, with a stack of original compositions under her belt. She won the talent contest doing her own rearrangement of Mary Wells’ Laughing Boy, which she reprised for Berry Gordy at her Hitsville audition. Just as he’d done with Wells herself, Gordy not only signed the girl up on the spot, but granted her the chance to cut her own material for her dĂ©but single.
There’s a fantastic account of all this in the liner notes to The Complete Motown Singles: Volume 3, which indicate that Gordy – perhaps burned by his bitter experience with Miss Teen USA Connie Van Dyke previously in the year – was keen to keep Miss Crawford’s family happy. She wasn’t to record anything until she turned 14, a condition which Gordy readily accepted. True to his word, he had a limo pick her up at midnight on her 14th birthday to ferry her and her chaperone over to the Motown studios, where Brian Holland and Lamont Dozier were waiting for her in the producers’ chairs. The lead vocal for Forget About Me, her dĂ©but single, was laid down that very night.
Not only is it a charming story, but it also goes a long way towards explaining what makes this record tick, both good and bad. Good first: it rocks. It’s a big, brassy single, a hair’s breadth away from turning into a marching 4/4 stomp but retaining just enough slinky sophistication in the verses to keep things from getting repetitive. A bruising kiss-off to a former lover, the song is clearly pitched several years in Carolyn’s future, but it’s highly entertaining.
Now the bad: perhaps it’s the late hour, or just the giddy enthusiasm of a young girl getting her big break, but Carolyn is out of control here. Perhaps unsure of the strengths of her own song, or maybe suddenly aware of her youth and inexperience, she tries to compensate by going right to the top of her lungs. Her extremely loud vocal is BLAM, right up in your face, especially during the raucous, glammy chorus, where she’s pretty much flat out shouting at you. But she can’t control herself, and the lyrics end up indistinct and garbled (if they were ever completely finished in the first place), meaning this comes across like a demo or guide vocal; the effect is very much one of attitude over technique.
Still, what an attitude. Holland-Dozier could have ordered more 4am retakes from the weary birthday girl, but it’s doubtful they’d have got anything better than what was already in the can – what Carolyn lacks in technical ability she makes up for in sheer energy, and her full-on delivery (which smacks of youth only in its lack of refinement, not in anything to do with pitch or timbre – she could pass easily enough for someone twice her age) lends the song a kind of pissed-off vigour its raw ingredients perhaps wouldn’t otherwise achieve.
Forget About Me failed to chart. Perhaps unsurprising, given all of the above, together with the fact that on closer examination the record goes absolutely nowhere – but there’s plenty of fun to be had on the journey anyway, and Carolyn was kept on the books for a few more releases yet. Definitely a case of “one to watch”.
MOTOWN JUNKIES VERDICT
(I’ve had MY say, now it’s your turn. Agree? Disagree? Leave a comment, or click the thumbs at the bottom there. Dissent is encouraged!)
You’re reading Motown Junkies, an attempt to review every Motown A- and B-side ever released. Click on the “previous” and “next” buttons below to go back and forth through the catalogue, or visit the Master Index for a full list of reviews so far.
(Or maybe you’re only interested in Carolyn Crawford? Click for more.)
Howard Crockett “That Silver Haired Daddy Of Mine” |
Carolyn Crawford “Devil In His Heart” |
DISCOVERING MOTOWN |
---|
Like the blog? Listen to our radio show! |
Motown Junkies presents the finest Motown cuts, big hits and hard to find classics. Listen to all past episodes here. |
Matt W. said:
Wow, I definitely think you underrated this one. It’s at least an 8 for me, and probably a 9. A forceful vocal for sure, but not overdone. I would liken it to Aretha Franklin’s Think or Respect. Not a quiet note to be found in those but I wouldn’t change him. She’s letting the son of a bitch HAVE it, and he no doubt deserves it! This one’s a personal fave.
LikeLiked by 1 person
tomovox said:
I agree. I’ve been listening to this for years and I’m just not hearing anything wrong with the delivery. You can’t sing an “EFF YOU” song in sedate, polite tones- permission granted to throw out technical perfection and go with that gut emotional performance.
Carolyn sold this song. And even if you can’t always make out the words, well entire careers have flourished on Rock artists who defy English translation.
Make mine an 8 for this one, please!
LikeLike
Salvador Harrison said:
I blame Berry Gordy for not pushing this 1963 unsung find to more exposure. At the time he was getting so hung up on The Supremes, especially Diana Ross, that he let some other great ones in his Motown line up fall through the cracks. Florence Ballard began the Supremes as lead singer but Berry backstabbed her & gave the group’s lead to Diana, leaving Flo in the background, & that turned out badly for her. & May she rip. Next The Marveletts. & Again Berry just let them fade away without trying for a save. Next Brenda Holloway, a beautiful girl in Motown, also in the early-mid 60s whose voice could nearly approach & pre-dated the late Whitney Houston’s sound, 50+ years earlier.
But again Berry was short sighted on some of his better singers. & Again, Carolyn Crawford here, of her song ‘Forget About Me’ 1963. Though she was in her mid teens the song was a good r&b/soul banger from Motown, with beats & harmonies that not only could’ve gone over big but could have introduced her & her sound to the world. There were other teenage singers & groups in his stable as well. Any flaws that might’ve been found could have been worked on & corrected.
Berry & Diana??? Though the Supremes had big hits, there were other better singers there than Diana as Florence’s voice was more soulful. Motown’s success covered over how he dropped the ball a few times.
Forget About Me by Carolyn Crawford, I can still listen to it time & again.
LikeLike
Matt W. said:
Oops… Should read “I wouldn’t change THEM” not “HIM.”
LikeLike
Topkat said:
Maybe it didn’t chart nationally, but it was certainly a hit in the Cleveland area. Deserved to be MUCH bigger than it got !!
LikeLike
Mickey The Twistin' Playboy said:
It was popular in Washington DC too and got her a booking at the Howard Theater before “My Smile” was released. Not the best of her releases but it’s good 8/10.
LikeLike
Dusty DJ Steve said:
How popular was this in DC? I grew up in DC but i don’t remember this one….. Maybe I thought iwas Mary Wells or soemthing…..but this is great record to say the least. I know WOOK played a whole lot of stuff…..
LikeLike
Drew said:
I saw her in Cleveland at The WHK Auditorium on a show headlined by The Radiants. She was absolutely charming. And the song was played in Cleveland quite a bit.
LikeLike
pete smith said:
This is the best record ever released on Motown. Criminally underrated, fantastic flipside too. 6 out of 10 does it a disservice.
LikeLike
The Nixon Administration said:
Obviously I disagree, but that’s not really the point. Rather, I’d be super keen to know why. I mean… The BEST record EVER released on Motown? That’s quite a statement there – what do you love about it?
LikeLike
Robb Klein said:
Really?? !! This just shows how different everyone’s taste is from everyone else. i am just about the biggest Carolyn Crawford fan there is. I think she has 3 of her 6 released Motown songs at the “super” level of 9 and 10, and also 2 more unreleased songs at 9 and 10. But, THIS song by her I rate at 7 at best 9on a good day (6.5 is more accurate). the song itself is not written well (no structure). It rambles all over the place like an Frank Wilson solo-written song. Carolyn sings it well, but it’s just a poorly-written song to me. Her great singing brings it up to 6.5 to 7.
LikeLike
144man said:
It never sounded more than a b-side to me. 6/10 is about right.
LikeLike
144man said:
…and I agree with Robb that the song is poor.
LikeLike
tomovox said:
I thought it interesting that, given the high standards and definite ideas Berry had for song structure, he would place Carolyn’s song on the A side. We all know Berry was a shrewd man and generally could sniff a hit at a thousand paces.
I have to believe that, much as he did with Smokey in the early days, Berry was allowing Carolyn space and opportunity to develop her craft. If it meant ceding a potential hit to a young girl’s efforts to develop her craft, then I’ve just gained more respect for Berry Gordy.
I also wonder if this may have gone a long way to impress Carolyn’s parents that Berry was genuinely interested in helping their daughter to get that all-important exposure as a bonafide song writer.
All of this is to say it’s a bit harsh to so thoroughly torpedo a 14 year-old’s early work (and one written by herself alone). If Berry saw fit to allow this girl a chance to grow, I think a bit of allowance could be made here. Who of us at 14, 15 could have written “The Perfect Song”?
LikeLike
Drew said:
I agree with those who say the song lacks structure but her enthusiastic vocal compensates somewhat.
LikeLike
bogart4017 said:
If her vocals were overly loud could that not be fixed in the mix?
This one didnt get a lot of play around my way and if it did we were still busy dancing the Monkey with Major Lance and the Jerk was right around the corner.
LikeLike
Abbott Cooper said:
I did not hear this at all on the R&B stations in NYC. So, when I finally did hear it 53 years later, my reaction, to quote a young Jerry Lewis: “I like it, I like it!” And to paraphrase Sally Field: “I REALLY like it.” Carolyn may have been loud, but her’s was a perfect Motown voice. A “9+” from me.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Salvador Harrison said:
I’ve been repeat playing this song ‘Forget About Me’ 1963, on YouTube over & again & think that it should’ve done waaay better. Maybe they could have done a little more work with her & reign her voice in a little bit, she was 14. If they had this could have been a big hit & Carolyn would have made more records & then possibly be as well known as other early-mid 60s female singers such as Diana Ross & Supremes, Mary Wells, Martha & The Vandellas, The Marvelettes, Kim Weston, & others. To it’s credit, the song was somewhat similar to other songs that were out back then. Many of them were rousing, enjoyable, r&b. But hers had a little more of a driven flavor. There were many dance numbers, but purposely watered down by Motown to be able to cross over from black audiences to lighter pop acceptance from the powers who ran the music charts, radio, etc. & was big in certain areas, just not nationally. Anyone who also loves this music as I do might enjoy searching on YouTube for ‘Northern Soul’. From dance parties popular in some places in England today that plays American mid 1960s black dance music. It’s r&b music from the early-mid 60s that wasn’t from Motown but often had a similar sound. But Carolyn’s song is still great to me.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Robb Klein said:
Wow! I like her singing on “Forget About Me”. But the song goes all over the place. I think she had a MUCH better chance of hitting it big with “My Smile Is Just A Frown, Turned Upside Down”, “I’ll Come Running”, and “When Someone’s Good To You”. If she didn’t have a major hit with those better songs written by Smokey and the far better of her own songs , she wasn’t going to have one with her flawed first effort.
LikeLike
James. said:
Fantastic tune, been looking for a reasonably priced copy of this on Vinyl. apart from Discogs ,anyone know where copies of this are being sold, thanks in advance.
LikeLike
Pete Rolland said:
Forget about me was an anthem for teenager females such as my older sister, when she changed her mind about possible suitors who turned out to be untrue.This song was very hard to dance to, but I loved the song because of its killer intro and message.Strictly a radio track but it stood the test of time.I have been a club dj for 50plus years and still get requests at reunions.most people don’t know the name of the song because it was not heavily promoted in the Chicago market.There is no screaming on the song.In 1990 I drove to Detroit to try to obtain a clean copy of the song, but hitsville u.s.a.didnt have one.I ended up in Toronto at Sam’s on Yonge St and they had one copy.well worth the trip.
LikeLiked by 1 person