377. The Serenaders: “If Your Heart Says Yes”
A shoddy, dated record, and poorly-sung and recorded to boot; not exactly the bottom of the barrel, but you can certainly see it from here. (2)
A shoddy, dated record, and poorly-sung and recorded to boot; not exactly the bottom of the barrel, but you can certainly see it from here. (2)
The phrase “hidden gem” is overused, not least by me, but it certainly applies here. (7)
A new start for everyone involved, a major step forward for the Motown Sound, and a damned fine pop record in its own right. Super. (8)
The narrator just comes across as such a buffoon that it’s hard to warm to this, even as unintentional comedy. (1)
Clocks in shy of two and a half minutes’ duration having had nowhere near the emotional impact it was looking for. A pity – this could really have been half-decent, too. (3)
Still not a great song by any means, but this is just about the best version of it that exists, and that counts for something. (6)
Not as good as Heat Wave, then, but – surprisingly – on balance a better, more vibrant and more exciting record than Quicksand.
The lyrical “twist ending” makes this a lot less fun; still listenable and everything, but somehow it all now seems so much sappier, so much less interesting. (4)
If you were to suggest this was a piece of throwaway novelty fluff there’s not much I could say in its defence, but nonetheless I think when it’s over, the good just about outweighs the bad. (5)
It’s not a bad little song, but it’s so badly performed that it’s actually painful to listen to in places, and that all comes down to the vocalist. Sorry, Patrice. (2)
Ultimately a weak record which is all the more frustrating because it could have been genuinely superb. A pity. (4)