Tags
Gordy G 7010 (A), October 1962
b/w Slow Down Heart
(Written by Berry Gordy)
The Temptations’ first official release since the magnificent (You’re My) Dream Come True seven months previously, this might have come too late to capitalise on that record’s minor chart placing.
Indeed, of the Temptations’ early, pre-stardom records, for my money this is the one which least stands up to repeated listening nowadays. Which isn’t to say it’s awful, or anything, but… Well, it sounds like a case of one step forward, two steps back. Allow me to explain.
Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons, a group of clean-cut white doo-woppers led by a helium-voiced falsetto, had been busy racking up the hits for Vee-Jay in 1962, having hit chart gold first time out with Sherry that summer. Berry Gordy, never slow to latch on to a popular trend, had no similar bunch of white doo-woppers on his books (the Valadiers had all but split up by this point, and in any case they didn’t have a falsetto to match Frankie Valli), but he did have the Temptations, who’d picked up an R&B chart hit with their last release – and the Tempts had Eddie Kendricks, a handsome, sweet-faced falsetto, albeit a bit rough and untutored at this point, who’d sung lead on that chart hit.
And so it came to pass that, rather than continue down the path of experimental harmonies and general R&B boundary-pushing that had produced (You’re My) Dream Come True and its even more outlandish predecessor Check Yourself, the Temptations were pushed back into a more familiar, less challenging doo-wop setting and aimed firmly towards the pop charts. Berry Gordy himself – who’d written and produced both those previous Tempts cuts – did the same here, hustling the group into the studio to record his own pastiche of Sherry.
The result? A number 122 pop hit, and a reasonably faithful, largely-unimpressive Four Seasons tribute record, which is to say a pretty much complete waste of the Temptations.
Eddie Kendricks had turned in a superb lead vocal on (You’re My) Dream Come True, but that was very much an exception to the rule – that one shining example aside, Eddie’s early performances had been uniformly disappointing, his raw, undisciplined squeal threatening to ruin every single side he’d been involved with. Have a listen to the Temptations’ début single Oh Mother Of Mine, for example, and its horrendous B-side Romance Without Finance, where he takes the lead jointly with Paul Williams, Eddie’s ear-splitting squawks almost overwhelming Paul’s more restrained performance; or perhaps Mind Over Matter, the record Motown had released just the previous week under the name “the Pirates”, where he again goes too loud and too high for both his bandmates and the backing track.
He’s on similar form here, probably not helped by the presumably explicit instructions to ape Frankie Valli’s rooftop-skimming high notes. The appeal of Frankie Valli doing that particular falsetto schtick was his style; it wasn’t just a question of being able to hit ludicrously high notes, but also a nasal, whiny delivery that helped him both enunciate his lyrics and harmonise with much lower backing vocals (a delivery which Valli is still doing at the time of writing, if the live performance videos on Youtube are anything to go by, despite being in his mid-seventies) and an innate ability to stay in tune (and in key!) whilst wheeling around the upper end of the vocal spectrum. Eddie Kendricks would go on to be one of the all-time great R&B voices, but those are tools that he simply didn’t have – and his problem in 1962 was that he was pushing too hard, aiming for the top of his register too often and with too little regard for the needs of the tune. An instruction to try and copy Frankie Valli was probably the least helpful advice Eddie could have received.
Whatever the reason, the results are really not a lot of fun to hear; it starts off tolerably with Eddie harmonising wordlessly with the other Tempts (Melvin Franklin’s anchoring bass is again a joy), until the lyrics begin at the 25-second mark; from then on in, he’s on his own, paying no attention to either the band or the rest of the group. He misses his mark at the start of literally every verse, and the rest of his performance is difficult to listen to; there’s a good bit in the middle when he dials it down a little and gets back into harmony with the others – the Don’t wanna wake up, don’t wanna wake up group refrain at 1:25 – which briefly raises hopes, but it’s over all too soon, and then we’re back to the substandard Frankie Valli impersonation.
It’s a step forward in the sense that it sounds easily the equal of the Frankie Valli record, Eddie notwithstanding – the rest of the Temptations sound vastly better than the Four Seasons, and when Eddie’s just harmonising with the group, the mix is beguiling; meanwhile, the band are on fine form, and the whole thing is a very professionally-packaged record. Two steps back, because (a) Eddie’s lead performance is awful, and shouldn’t really have been encouraged, and (b) this wouldn’t be regarded as a one-off misfire, meaning the Temptations would waste a lot of time over the next year and a half being pushed down the packaged pop act road, releasing two underwhelming singles, I Want A Love I Can See and Farewell My Love, neither of which made any impression whatsoever on the charts. The group wouldn’t be treated to any high-quality new material that played to their unique strengths until Smokey Robinson took them firmly in hand in 1964.
This record seems to be much-beloved by Temptations fans, but I’m stumped if I can work out why. Easily the weakest of the various singles the Temptations had released thus far, this is ironically nowhere near as good as the group’s quickly-recorded “Pirates” novelty cash-in 45 from the previous week, Mind Over Matter (and certainly not up to the standard of its lovely B-side I’ll Love You Till I Die); even if Eddie had been note-perfect, this would have been a slight, enjoyable but largely forgettable doo-wop number. It’s still harmless enough fun, but scarcely more than that – and that yowling lead vocal knocks this down to a below par effort from the Tempts in my book. I do look forward to the disagreements.
MOTOWN JUNKIES VERDICT
(I’ve had MY say, now it’s your turn. Agree? Disagree? Leave a comment, or click the thumbs at the bottom there. Dissent is encouraged!)
You’re reading Motown Junkies, an attempt to review every Motown A- and B-side ever released. Click on the “previous” and “next” buttons below to go back and forth through the catalogue, or visit the Master Index for a full list of reviews so far.
(Or maybe you’re only interested in The Temptations? Click for more.)
The Vells “There He Is (At My Door)” |
The Temptations “Slow Down Heart” |
Dave L said:
You seem almost forlorn, NixonRadio, for some debate and disagreement, and I’m old enough to know never to say never, so we may yet. But not yet.
Put it this way: when I finally scored a Gordy 45 of this one in the mid-70s, I had to settle for the later, ‘arrow’ label and not the script one. Since then, I haven’t broken my neck or gutted any bank account for a first pressing.
As you seem to know, we can’t judge these ‘try & error period’ releases on The Tempts by the standard of their later magnificence. If Berry indeed played “Sherry” for Eddie and told him to sound like that, then Berry deserves as much or more blame as Eddie for testing our ears the way this record does. If this had come out after Smokey & Norman had learned the proper way to showcase Eddie’s voice, then yes, clobbering would be due all around. It’s eye-widening just to ponder this is the same voice that’s going to someday give us “Just My Imagination.”
Of the pre-The Way You Do… material, I think I’ve got the most warmth for “I Want A Love I Can See” and “The Further You Look.” When we get to that one, if you manage to hatchet either with 3s, 2s or 1s, maybe I can summon more indignation.
Or maybe not. When you genuinely shocked me giving The Supremes’ “I Want A Guy” your highest rating, you made me want not to quarrel, but go back to the song for re-examination, and maybe joy to be had that I missed. I’m obviously in the company of a first-rate Motown scholar, who loves the record company and the deathless music it created as I do, and is as eager as I to read anything having to do with it. That rather makes you among the last persons I’d ever view adversarially. 🙂
LikeLike
Robb Klein said:
I agree that “I Want A Love I Can See” is the Best Temptations pre- “The Way You Do The Things You Do” cuts.
LikeLike
YourOldStandBy said:
This is a really nice record and although you make comparisons to Valli, I don’t think it was an effort to copy the Four Seasons sound. I mean, maybe a little. But you couldn’t really imagine the Seasons doing this song. Oh no – it’s a Motown record all the way. I’m not even a hard-core Temptations fan, but for me this is their finest moment. I love the way the drums are in this record – those fills are killer and you can hear them in many other early Motown/Tamla/Gordy 60s records. Score – 7
LikeLike
nixonradio said:
Thanks YOSB. I’ve just never understood the love that seems to be out there for this record. I mean, I agree the band are on crackling form, but for this to be someone’s favourite Temptations record (and you’re not the first person I’ve heard that from, by any means)… well, when people tell me they spat their drink out when they read how much I love the Supremes’ debut I Want A Guy, I guess I know how they feel. 😉
This is why I love the Internet, though. Dissent, as always, is encouraged.
In an ironic twist, Frankie Valli did actually end up signing with Motown in the Seventies. I probably should have mentioned that in the review, on further reflection.
LikeLike
Robb Klein said:
I agree that this was NOT an attempt to copy Frankie Valli’s Four Seasons’ style. This is pure R&B group harmony style, with a Falsetto lead. THAT is definitely NOT Four Seasons style. If you’ll pay attention to any Four Seasons’ cut, you’ll find that that group did NOT sing harmonies. They had a falsetto lead singer, and 3 background singers singing the same notes, in the same key, at the same time. A good example of a Motown group emulating The Four Season’s sound was 1964’s “Cry”, sung by The Majestics (soon-to-be-known as “The Monitors”). That was a Jobete song that would have been a smash hit by The Four Seasons in mid 1964. Too bad Motown didn’t release it. It would have gotten Richard Street’s Monitors group going a whole year earlier, and given them a better place in Motown’s artist hierarchy, as The Supremes, and Four Tops hadn’t yet become so very big at that time, and The Spinners were just coming into their own.
LikeLike
Rupert Kinnard said:
Damn you! I have enough internet addictions and now this site? Today will go down in history as my first response top what I see as an amazing Motown site. It is clear that I am such a Motown fan, I will disagree with much of what you ahve to say about songs that I accept as great. Bit you clearly bring such passion and knowledge to what you write…I will always respect you!
Now…Paradise. All I will say is that I love singing alone with Eddie on this tune and being the die-hard Tempts fan that I am, I know the degree to which I can’t be objective. Any faults one might find with Eddie’s vocals might be justified but I just love the way he attacks the lyrics. Yes…I do dissent! Love ya dude. You will be hearing so much from me in the future, you may get sick of me!
LikeLike
The Nixon Administration said:
Welcome to the site, Rupert! Glad you’re enjoying. No worries about disagreement, I’m well aware my opinions aren’t exactly widely shared. For balance, I do consider Dream Come True one of the best records in Motown’s history…
LikeLike
Robb Klein said:
I wouldn’t say it is one of my favourite Temptations tunes. But I certainly would give it a LOT more than a 4! I’d give it a 6.7 (olympic diving score). Just short of a 7, I’d say. One of Eddie’s leads IS my favourite Temptations’ cut (and it was never released on vinyl: “A Tear From A Woman’s Eyes”. We had it slated for release on Motown’s “From The Vaults” album series. But, sadly, the project was dropped after the first album died with almost no sales.
“Paradise” is a nice “DooWoppy” sound for early 1962. I bought it after one listen.
LikeLike
Landini said:
Hey buddy! To my ears, this sounds a bit like a cross between “Sherry” & “Stay” by the Zodiacs. I was impressed that “Meet The Temptations” actually scraped the album charts (# 95 I think). That was very, very good for a fairly unknown black group at that time. Hope all is with ya. Peace!
PS – totally unrelated but do you know anything about the Superlatives who did “I Still Love You” a Northern Soul/Motownish tune which I am sure you know. I think it is a pretty cool song. I heard it on a rare oldies show here in Baltimore, MD a few years back.
LikeLike
Robb Klein said:
Yes. I have “I Still Love You” by The Superlatives. They were a Baltimore group, I believe. Nothing to do with Detroit. There WAS, however, a Detroit Superlatives group, who recorded in the late 1960s, for the local Dynamics Records, and also appeared on Armen Boladian’s Westbound Records.
LikeLike
DE Mount said:
It has great backing vocals and a backbeat with a propulsive groove, but the lead vocals are just unhinged. Coming to some of these songs with a fresh perspective and having not heard this track before, I’d have to concur that the lead vocals are off-putting at least and certrainly detract from the overall effect. A different lead track and this could have been killer.
LikeLike
The Nixon Administration said:
Yep, that’s it in a nutshell, I feel. Sadly it would be too dated to succeed by the time Eddie could sing it right a couple of years later.
LikeLike
bogart4017 said:
Its the band, man! Those cats were on fire that night! 7/10.
LikeLike
benjaminblue said:
To my ears, the verse of this song and Eddie’s singing sound like an impression of Frankie Valli doing his impression of Maurice Williams’ “Stay.” In fact, it’s an almost-note-by-note copy.
LikeLike
Bruce Grossberg said:
I never thought of the Valli connection before and although there are similarities in parts of the song, it’s unconvincing to say the Tempts copied the Seasons. Sherry was released in mid-Aug’62, the Temps recorded Paradise in late Aug ’62. It’s unlikely Gordy copied the song since it first entered the charts on Aug 25 at #65. Even if Gordy head it that first week (which is doubtful), there was no indication it would become a monster hit. The following week, it was still only #22 & the Temps had already completed the session for Paradise by then.
LikeLike