168. The Marvelettes: “Playboy”
If the stellar, never-to-be-recaptured magic of their début single had been something of a quirk, a statistical oddity if not an outright fluke, then in many ways the Marvelettes’ story really begins right here. (6)
If the stellar, never-to-be-recaptured magic of their début single had been something of a quirk, a statistical oddity if not an outright fluke, then in many ways the Marvelettes’ story really begins right here. (6)
Hardly a patch on the stellar A-side, this is still a very good record well worth a listen. (6)
A gorgeous song, the first truly great Miracles ballad.
This isn’t quite all it’s cracked up to be; it’s very pretty but quite meandering, effectively consisting of three great bits linked with a lot of unmemorable fluff. (4)
Probably the best of Eddie’s three Motown singles to date, and the writing credit means it’s a Historically Significant record to boot; it shows plenty of promise and development, and it’s a good little record, but there was still significantly better to come from Edward Holland Jr. as both a singer and as a writer. (6)
A fun, frothy, meaningless doo-wop ditty, which coming from a group like the Temptations is both highly enjoyable and maddeningly limited. (6)
Possibly the best song Berry Gordy ever wrote, and therefore fitting that it should appear on the label bearing his name. But huge credit is also due to both the band and to the group; it is, after all, what’s in the grooves that count(s). (10)
Highly generic Fifties rock ‘n’ roll, at least five years behind the curve. (2)
A historical artefact and nothing more, then; not worth seeking out unless you really, really like Duke Of Earl, and even then it’ll probably just annoy you. (2)
This is barely-listenable garbage, a bad execution of a poorly thought-out idea which should never have been released. (1)
Not a particularly good record, all in all, and not suited to either the singer or the direction in which Motown was now firmly headed. (4)